Friday, 11 November 2016

Trial balance

TRIAL BALANCE
After the transactions are posted to various ledger accounts (either from journal or from subsidiary books) and they are balanced, the next stage is to draw up the list of all balances.  We know that some ledger accounts will show ‘debit balance’ (debit side greater than the credit side), while the other will reflect a ‘credit balance’ (Credit side being higher than debit side).  All account balances are listed to ensure that the total of all debit balances equals the total of all credit balances.  Why does this happen?  Remember the dual aspect concept studied earlier in this study note? According to this concept, every debit has equal corresponding credit.  This list of balances is called Trial Balance.

According to the Dictionary for Accountants by Eric.L.Kohler, Trial Balances id defined as “ a list or abstract of the balances or of total debits and total credits of the accounts in a ledger, the purpose being to determine the equality of posted debits and credits and to establish a basic summary for financial statements”. According to Rolland, “The final list of balances, totaled and combined, is called Trial Balance.

As this is merely a listing of balances, this will always be as on a particular date.  Further it must be understood that trial balance does not form part of books of account, but it is a report prepared by extracting balances of accounts maintained in the books of accounts.

When this list with tallied debit and credit balances is drawn up, the arithmetical accuracy of basic entries, ledger posting and balancing is ensured.  However, it does not guarantee that the entries are correct in all respect.  This will be explained later this chapter.

Although it is supposed to be prepared at the end of accounting period, computerized accounting packages are capable of providing instant Trial Balance reports even on daily basis, as the transactions are recorded almost on line.

Let us prepare the Trial balance for the ledger accounts from the following illustration.

2014
April
1 Mr. Vikas and Mrs.Vaibhavi who are husband and wife start consulting business by bringing in their personal cash of Rs.5,00,000 and 250000 respectively.
10 Bought office furniture of Rs.25000 for cash bill no.2014/f/3
11 Opened a current account with Punjab National Bank by depositing Rs.100000
15 paid office rent of Rs.15000 for the monthby cheque to M/s Realtors proprieties. Voucher No.3
20 Bought a motor car worth Rs.450000 fro Millennium Motors by making a down payment of Rs.50000 by cheque and the balance by taking a loan from HDFC bank. Voucher No.M/13/7
25 Vikas and Vaibhavi carried out a consulting assignment for Avon Pharmaceuticals and raised a bill for Rs.1000000 as consultancy fees.  Bill no.B13/4/1 raised.  Avon Pharmaceuticals have immediately settled Rs.250000 by way of cheque and the balance will be paid after 30 days.  The cheque received is deposited into bank.
30 Sale of one receptionist @ Rs.5000 per month and one officer @ Rs.10000 per month.  The salary for the current month is payable to them.
Solution:
The entries for these transactions in a journal will look like:
Date
Particulars
Voucher Number
Ledger folio
Debit amount
Credit amount
01.04.14
Cash A/c                              Dr.
To Vikas’s Capital A/c
To Vaibhavi’s Capital A/c
(Being capital brought in by the partners)

1
2
3
750000

500000
250000

10.04.14
Furniture A/c                Dr.
To Cash A/c
(Being furniture purchased in cash)
2014/F/3
4
1
25000

25000
11.04.14
Punjab National Bank A/c    Dr.
To Cash A/c
(Being current account opened with Punjab national bank by depositing cash)

5
1
100000

100000
15.04.14
Rent A/c                   Dr.
To Punjab National Bank A/c
(Being rent paid to realtors properties for the month)
3
6
5
15000

15000
20.04.14
Motor Car A/c                    Dr.
To Punjab National bank A/c
To Loan from HDFC Bank A/c
(Being car purchased from Millennium motors by paying down payment and loan arrangement)
M/13/7
7
5
8
450000

50000
400000
25.04.14
Punjab National Bank A/c    Dr.
Avon Pharmaceuticals A/c   Dr.
To Consultancy Fees A/c
(Being amount received and revenue recognized for fees charged)
B13/4/1
5
9
10
250000
750000


1000000
30.04.14
Salary A/c                          Dr.
To Salary Payable A/c
(Being the entry to record salary obligation for the month)

11
12
15000

15000

                                                                                                                                                              Folio No. 1
Cash –Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
01.04.14
To Vikas’s Capital A/c
1
500000
10.04.14
By Furniture A/c
1
  25000
01.04.14
To Vaibhavi’s Capital A/c
1
250000
11.04.14
By Punjab National Bank A/c
1
100000




30.04.14
By Balance C/d

625000



750000



750000
01.05.14
To Balance b/c

625000





                                                                                                                                                               Folio No. 2
Mr.Vikas’s Capital Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount

To balance b/d

500000
1.04.14
By cash A/c
1
500000



500000



500000








                                                                                                                                                        Folio No.3
Mrs.Vaibhavi’s Capital Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount

To balance b/d

250000
01.04.14
By Cash A/c
1
250000



250000



250000

                                                                                                                                                       



Folio No. 4
Furniture Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
10.04.14
To Cash A/c

25000

By balance b/d

25000



25000



25000

                                                                                                                                                        Folio No. 5

Punjab National Bank Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
11.04.14
To Cash A/c
1
100000
15.04.14
By Rent A/c
1
15000
25.04.14
To Consultancy Fees A/c
1
250000
20.04.14
By Motor Car a/c
1
50000





By balance

285000



350000



350000
                                                                               
                                                                                                                                                        Folio No. 6
Rent Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
15.04.14
To Punjab National Bank A/c
1
15000

By balance

15000



15000



15000

                                                                                                                                                        Folio No.7
 Motor Car Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
20.04.14
To Punjab National bank a/c
1
50000

By balance

450000
20.04.14
To Loan from HDFC Bank A/c
1
400000







450000



450000
       
                                                                                                                                                       


Folio No. 8
Loan from HDFC Bank Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount

To balance

400000
20.04.14
By Motor Car A/c
1
400000



400000



400000

Avon Pharmaceuticals Account                        Folio no. 9
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
25.04.14
To Consultancy fee A/c
1
750000

By balance

750000



750000



750000
                                                       

                                                                                                                                                        Folio No. 10
Consultancy Fees Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount

To balance

1000000
25.04.14
By Punjab national Bank A/c
1
250000




25.04.14
By Avon Pharmaceuticals a/c
1
750000



1000000



1000000
                                                                                                                                                        Folio No. 11
Salary Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
30.04.14
To Salary Payable a/c
1
15000

By balance

15000



15000



15000
                                                                                                                                                        Folio No. 12
 Salary Payable Account
Dr                                                                                                                                                                   Cr
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount
Date
Particulars
J.F
Amount

To balance

15000
30.04.14
By Salary A/c

15000



15000



15000




Trial Balance as on
Account Name
Debit
Credit
Cash A/c
6,25,000

Vikas’s Capital A/c

5,00,000
Vaibhavi’s Capital A/c

2,50,000
Furniture
   25,000

Punjab National Bank A/c
2,85,000

Rent A/c
    15,000

Motor Car
4,50,000

Loan from HDFC A/c

4,00,000
Avon Pharmaceuticals
7,50,000

Consultancy fees A/c

10,00,000
Salary A/c
   15,000

Salary Payable A/c

   15,000
Total
21,65,000
21,65,000

It can be seen that the totals of debit and credit balances is exactly matching.  This is the result of double entry book-keeping wherein every debit has equal corresponding credit. 

Feature’s of a Trial Balance
1.       It is a list of debit and credit balances which are extracted from various ledger accounts.
2.       It is a statement of debit and credit balances.
3.       The purpose is to establish arithmetical accuracy of the transactions recorded in the Books of Accounts.
4.       It does not prove arithmetical accuracy which can be determined by audit.
5.       It is not an account.  It is only a statement of account.
6.       It is not a part of the final statements.
7.       It is usually prepared at the end of the accounting year but it can also be prepared anytime as and when required like weekly, monthly, quarterly or half-yearly.
8.       It is a link between books of accounts and the profit and loss account and balance sheet.
Preparation of Trial Balance:
1.       It may be prepared on a loose sheet of paper
2.       The ledger accounts are balanced at first.  They will have either “debit-balance” or “Credit-balance” or “nil-balance”.
3.       The accounts having debit-balance is written on the debit column and those having credit-balance are written on the credit column.
The sum total of both the balances must be equal, for “Every debit has its corresponding and equal credit”.
                Purpose of a Trial Balance
                It serves the following purposes:
1.       To check the arithmetical accuracy of the recorded transactions.
2.       To ascertain the balance of any ledger account.
3.       To serve as an evidence of fact that the double entry has been completed in respect of every transaction.
4.       To facilitate the preparation of final accounts promptly.
Is Trial Balance Indispensable?
It is a mere statement prepared by the accountants of his own convenience and if it agrees, it is assumed that at least arithmetical accuracy has been done although there may be a lot of errors.
Trial balance is not a process of accounts, but its preparation helps us to finalize the accounts.  Since it is prepared on a particular date, as at ------------ / as on  ----------- is stated.
Forms of a Trial Balance
A trial balance may be prepared in two forms, they are-
1.       Journal form
2.       Ledger Form
The trial balance must tally irrespective of the form of a trial balance.
1.       Journal Form: This form of a Trial Balance will have a format of journal folio.  It will have a column for serial number, name of the account, ledger folio, debit amount and credit amount columns in this journal form.
The ledger folio will show the page number on which such account appears in the ledger.
Specimen of Journal form of Trial balance:

Trial Balance as on --------
Sl.No.
Name of the Account
L.F
Debit Balance
Credit Balance






2.       Ledger Form: This form of a trial balance have two sides i.e. debit side and credit side.  In fact, the ledger form of a trial balance is prepared in the form of an account.  Each side of the trial balance will have particulars (name of the account) column, folio column and the amount column.
Specimen of ledger form of Trial balance

Dr.                                                                          Trial balance as on --------------                                   Cr.
Name of the Account
L.F
Amount
Name of the Account
L.F
Amount









Methods of Preparation
1.       Total Method or Gross Trial balance.
2.       Balance Method or Net Trial Balance.
3.       Compound Method

These are explained as under:-
1.       Total Method or Gross Trial balance: Under this method, two sides of the accounts are totaled.  The total of the debit side is called the “debit total” and the total of the credit side is called the “credit total”.  Debit totals are entered on the debit side of the Trial balance while the credit total is entered on the credit side of the Trial balance.
If a particular account has total in one side, it will be entered either in the debit column or the credit column as the case may be.
Advantages:
a)      It facilitates arithmetical accuracy of the accounts.
b)      Extraction of ledger balances is not required at the time of preparation of Trial balance.
Disadvantages:
Preparation of Final accounts is not possible.
2.       Balance Method or Net Trial Balance: under this method, all the ledger accounts are balanced.  The balances may be either “Debit-balance” or “Credit balance”
Advantages:
a)      It helps in the easy preparation of final accounts.
b)      It saves time and labour in constructing a Trial balance.
Disadvantages:
Errors may remain undisclosed irrespective of the agreement of Trial Balance.
3.       Compound Method: Under this method, totals of both the sides of the accounts are written in the separate columns.  Along with this, the balances are also written in the separate columns.  Debit balances are written in the debit column and credit balances are written in the credit column of the Trial balance.
Advantages: It offers the advantage of both the methods.
Disadvantages: Lengthy process and more time consumed in the preparation of Trial balance.

Summary of Rules
Debit Balance – All assets, Drawings, Debtors, Expenses and losses.
Credit Balance – All liabilities, Capital, Creditors, Gains and Incomes.

Trial balance – Utility and Interpretation
The utility of Trial balance could be found in the following:
1.       It forms the basis for preparation of financial statements i.e. Profit and Loss Account and balance Sheet.
2.       A tallied trial balance ensures the arithmetical accuracy of the entries made.  If the trial balance does not tally, the errors can be found out, rectified and then financial statements can be prepared.
3.       It acts as a quick reference.  One can easily find out the balance in any ledger account without actually referring to the ledger.
4.       If the listing of ledger accounts is systematically done in the trial balance, one can do quick time analysis.  Hence, listing is usually done in the sequence of Asset accounts, liability accounts, Capital accounts, Owner’s equality accounts, Income or gain accounts and Expenses or losses accounts in that order.

One can draw some quick inference from trial balance by interpreting the same.  If one plots monthly trial balances side by side, one can analyze the movement of balances in various accounts e.g. one can see how expenses are increasing or decreasing or showing a trend of movements.  By comparing the owner’s equity balances as on two dates, one can interpret the business result e.g. if the equity has gone up, one can interpret that business has earned net profit and vice versa.
                Trial Balance and Errors
                     We have seen that a tallied trial balance (T.B) ensures arithmetical accuracy.  What does it mean? It means entries have been passed as per double entry, that every debit has equal corresponding credit.  If the T.B does not tally, there could be errors in transaction entry.  Such errors are called ‘ Errors affecting trial balance’. These can be
a.       Only one effect of a transaction is posted to ledger e.g. for rent paid in cash, if entry is posted to cash but not to rent account, then obviously the T.B. will not match.
b.      Posting of wrong amount in one of the ledger e.g. rent of Rs.1000 is paid in cash.  The posting to Rent a/c is done for Rs.1000,  Cash A/c is recorded at Rs.10,000.  The T.B will not tally.
c.       If one of the posting is entered twice, T.B. will not match.
d.      If the balance in a ledger is not correctly taken to the T.B. e.g. the Rent A/c has a balance of Rs.1000, but while taking it to the T.B. it is taken as Rs.100, the T.B. will through up difference.
e.      Taking balance to the wrong side in the T.B. e.g. a debit balance of Rs.5,00,000 in Debtors A/c is taken as credit balance in the TB, the there will be a mismatch.
f.        Wrong carry forwards also will result in the T.B. mismatch.
No financial statements can be prepared if the T.B. does not tally.  Hence, the errors will have to be rectified before proceeding further.  The accountants therefore endeavour to minimize errors by being more care full and be doing periodical scrutiny of the entries.
Errors which are not disclosed by a Trial Balance
The following errors cannot be detected by a Trial Balance:
a.       Errors of Omission: when the transaction is not at all recorded in the books of accounts, i.e. neither in the debit sider not in the credit side of the account – trial balance will agree.
b.      Errors of Commission: Where there is any variation in figure/amount, e.g. instead of Rs.800 either Rs.80/- or Rs.8000 is recorded, in both sides of ledger accounts – trial balance will agree.
c.       Errors of Principal:  When accounts are prepared not according to double entry principle e.g. purchase of a plant wrongly debited to Purchase account – Trial balance will agree.
d.      Errors of Misposting: When wrong posting is made to a wrong account instead of a correct one although amount is correctly recorded, e.g. sold goods to B but wrongly debited to D’s Account – trial balance will agree.
e.      Compensating Errors: When one error is compensated by another error e.g. Discount Allowed Rs.100 not debited to Discount Allowed Account, whereas interest received Rs.100, but not credit to interest Account – trial balance will agree.
Procedure to locate Errors:
If the Trial Balance does not agree, the following procedure should carefully be followed.
1.       At first, check all ledger account balance one by one.
2.       Addition of both the columns (Debit and Credit) should be checked.
3.       If any difference comes divide the same by 2 and see whether the said figure appears on the correct side or not.
4.       Additions of the subsidiary books, and ledger accounts to be checked up.
5.       Posting from subsidiary books to the ledger to be checked up.
6.       Opening balance of all account whether brought forward correctly or not to be checked up.
7.       Even if the trial balance does not agree up to this level checking should be started again from the journal and book of original entry using tick mark.





AT A GLANCE
Trial balances as at / as on  ……….
Head of Accounts
Side of Trial Balance
Reasons
Cash in hand
Debit
Assets
Cash at Bank
Debit
Assets
Cash at Bank (Overdrawn)
Credit
Liability
Bank overdraft
Credit
Liability
Capital
Credit
Liability
Opening stock
Debit
Assets
Wages
Debit
Expenses
Purchase
Debit
Expenses / increase in stock
Carriage inwards
Debit
Expenses
Freight
Debit
Expenses
Royalty on production
Debit
Expenses
Gas, water, fuel
Debit
Expenses
Motive power
Debit
Expenses
Import duty
Debit
Expenses
Sales
Credit
Income / decrease in stock
Discount allowed
Debit
Losses
Discount received
Credit
Gains
Bad debts
Debit
Losses
Reserve / Provision for bad & doubtful debt (opening)
Credit
Gains (Part of Retained Earnings)
Commission received
Credit
Incomes
Salaries
Debit
Expenses
Commission paid
Debit
Expenses
Rent, rates and taxes
Debit
Expenses
Repair and maintenance
Debit
Expenses
Insurance
Debit
Expenses
Carriage outward
Debit
Expenses
Trade charges
Debit
Expenses
Royalty on sales
Debit
Expenses
Interest paid
Debit
Expenses
Interest received
Credit
Income
Advertisement
Debit
Expenses
Sundry expenses
Debit
Expenses
Miscellaneous expenses
Debit
Expenses
Miscellaneous receipts
Credit
Incomes
Income tax
Debit
Drawings / Assets
L.I.C. Premium
Debit
Drawings / Assets
Office expenses
Debit
Expenses
Export duty
Debit
Expenses
Allowances
Debit
Losses
Rebates
Debit
Losses
Sales tax
Debit
Expenses
Horses and Carts
Debit
Assets
Watch Dag Squad
Debit
Assets
Loan Secured
Credit
Liability
Loans advanced
Debit
Assets
Reserve funds
Credit
Liability
Sinking fund
Credit
Liability
Sinking fund investments
Debit
Assets
Ecology fund
Credit
Liability
Ecology fund investments
Debit
Assets
Building fund
Credit
Liability
Building
Debit
Assets
Land
Debit
Assets
Plant
Debit
Assets
Machinery
Debit
Assets
Furniture and fittings
Debit
Assets
Motor vehicles
Debit
Assets
Computer
Debit
Assets
Office equipments
Debit
Assets
Goodwill
Debit
Assets
Patent rights
Debit
Assets
Copyrights
Debit
Assets
Trade marks
Debit
Assets
Investments
Debit
Assets
Shares & securities
Debit
Assets
G.P.Notes
Debit
Assets
Sundry debtors
Debit
Assets
Sundry creditors
Credit
Liability
General reserve
Credit
Liability
Bill receivable
Debit
Assets
Bills payable
Credit
Liability
Provision for discount on Debtors
Credit
Liability
Provision for discount on Creditors
Debit
Assets
Lighting and Heating
Debit
Expenses
Drawings
Debit
Assets
Contribution to Provident Fund
Debit
Assets
Prize fund
Credit
Liability
Depreciation
Debit
Losses
Provision for depreciation
Credit
Liability
Returns inwards
Debit
Losses
Returns outwards
Credit
Gains
Freehold property
Debit
Assets
Premises
Debit
Assets
Leasehold property
Debit
Assets
Loose tools
Debit
Assets
Petty cash
Debit
Assets
Provident fund
Credit
Liability
Debenture Purchased
Debit
Assets
Debentures (from public)
Credit
Liability
Loan on mortgage
Credit
Liability
Prepaid expenses
Debit
Assets
Outstanding expenses
Credit
Liability
Bad Debits recovered
Credit
Gains
Accrued incomes
Debit
Assets
Apprenticeship premium received
Credit
Income
Books
Debit
Assets
Newspaper and magazine
Debit
Expenses
Profit and loss A/c (Dr.)
Debit
Losses
Profit and loss A/c (Cr.)
Credit
Gains
Accumulated depreciation
Credit
Liability
Postage and telegram
Debit
Expense
Travelling and conveyance
Debit
Expenses




Illustration:
From the following ledger account balances, prepare a trial balance of Mr.Sen for the year ended 31st martch, 2015
Capital Rs.80000; Sales Rs.1000000; Adjusted Purchase Rs.800000; Current A/c (Cr) Rs.10000; Petty Cash Rs.10000; Sales Ledger balance Rs.120000; Purchase ledger balance Rs.60000; Salaries Rs.24000; Carriage inwards Rs.4000; Carriage Outward Rs.6000; Discount Allowed Rs.10000; Building Rs.80000; Outstanding expenses Rs.10000; Prepaid Insurance Rs.2000; Depreciation Rs.4000; Cash at Bank Rs.80000; Loan A/c (Cr) Rs.66000; Profit & loss A/c (Cr) Rs.20000; Bad debts Recovered Rs.2000;Stock as 31.03.15 Rs.120000; Interest Received Rs.10000; Accrued interest Rs.4000; Investment Rs.20000; Provision for bad debts (01.04.14) Rs.6000; General Reserve Rs.20000.

Solution
Trial balance of Mr.Sen as on 31-03-2015
Dr                                                                                                                                                                                           Cr.
Head of Accounts
Amount
Head of Accounts
Amount
Adjusted purchase
800000
Capital
    80000
Petty cash
   10000
Sales
1000000
Sales ledger balance
120000
Current A/c
    10000
Salaries
24000
Purchase ledger balance
60000
Carriage inward
  4000
Outstanding Expenses
10000
Discount Allowed
10000
Loan A/c
66000
Building
80000
Profit and Loss A/c
20000
Prepaid insurance
  2000
Bad debits Recovered
  2000
Depreciation
  4000
Interest Received
10000
Cash at Bank
 80000
Provision for Bad Debts
  6000
Stock (31.03.15)
120000
General Reserve
20000
Accrued Interest
    4000


Investment
  20000


Carriage outward
     6000



1284000

1284000